Early buddhist metaphysics this book provides a philosophical account of the major doctrinal shift in the history of early theravada tradition in india. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy studies in indian and tibetan buddhism kindle edition by dunne, john d download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy pdf free download epdf. Foundations of dharmakirtis philoso phy srwjin in itulutn,,u tilntan bruijhismprovick i forum for pii liahifll. Turning back the linguistic turn in the theory of knowledge. If we go by tibetan sources, he seems to have been born in south india and then to have moved to the great monastic university of nalanda in present day bihar state where he was supposedly in contact with other buddhist. Similar concepts and descriptions of energy and information patterns exist in various cultures and have guided whole systems of medicine such as ayurveda and tibetan medicine. State university of new york press, 1997 the sound of two hands clapping. The same nonantidualism lays at the foundation of davidsons arguments. Dharmakirtis argument from immutibility for atheism god is immutable. Buddhist philosophy wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy studies in indian. Dharmakirtis theory of hetucentricity of anumana masaaki. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading foundations of dharmakirti s philosophy studies in indian and tibetan buddhism.
One blade of grass tells the story of how meditation practice helped henry shukman to recover from the depression, anxiety, and chronic eczema he had had since childhood and to integrate a sudden spiritual awakening into his life. This idea of the criteria of reality provides a theoretical basis for the authors. Lucid and carefully argued, dunnes work serves both as an introduction to dharmakirti for students of buddhism and a groundbreaking resource for. They maintain that to achieve those ends, one must eliminate ignorance avidya, a fundamental mental flaw that is sufferings basic cause. Journal of the bihar and orissa research society, 243263 issued as appendices. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy, a substantial revision of john dunnes doctoral dissertation, is a welldocumented and clearly argued. Dunne foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy by john d. Throughout the history of buddhism, few philosophers have attained the stature of dharmakirti, the lord of reason who has influenced virtually every systematic buddhist. Dharmakirti s synthesis is the apex of buddhist philosophy, at the moment when it was institutionally fading. Dharmakirti s philosophy and its tibetan interpretations.
Dreyfus examines the central ideas of dharmakirti, one of the most important indian buddhist philosophers, and their reception among tibetan thinkers. His methodological scepticism compelled him to reject the authority of buddhist scriptures except when they withstood the same rigorous dialectical examination to which he. Atheology and buddhalogy in dharmakirtis pramanavarttika, faith and philosophy 16 1999 472505. Christian coseru, college of charleston on about the author. Double negation in buddhist logic, journal of indian philosophy, 3. Nigrahasthana is the occasion of defeat what we would call a fallacy. Dharmakirtis selfengendered conversion convinced him that buddha is the ultimate source of all knowledge, leading him to try to unravel the inner logic of the teachings. Buddhist logicoepistemology or buddhist logic, buddhist epistemology is used in western scholarship to refer to buddhist traditions of prama. Eltschinger 2010, an outstanding articlelength presentation of dharmakirtis thought, gives. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy stands as one of the most innovative and sophisticated attempts to engage with dharmakirtis project in a systematic way.
Her research interests include a range of issues associated with indian theravada buddhist philosophy and psychology, the abhidhamma tradition and comparative indian philosophy. Chaptertwoofdharmakirtispramanavarttika advancedbuddhist. Revisions respond to feedback from students and teachers and make the volume even more. Raymond tallis has a measured response to numbered seconds. Dharmakirtis tradition in india and tibet the epistemological turn in indian philosophy the place of dharmakirti in indian buddhism dharmakirtis tradition in tibet foundation of the sagya scholastic tradition a conflict of interpretations sagya commentators the rise of the geluk tradition the origin and significance of sectarian divisions. Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy stillness speaks. Despite not being organized along the lines of formal logic, dharmakirtis inference emerges as a theory of deductive inference with an economy of. Alan brody explains platossocrates understanding of habitually bad behavior. Most of the questions addressed in those discussions are simply irrelevant to. Download pdf dharmakirti on the duality of the object free. The socalled linguistic turn in philosophy intensified rather than overcame the rationalism that has haunted western ideas about knowledge since antiquity.
Dharmakirtis logic is an excellent weapon for a critical and a dialectical refutation of all beliefs unwarranted by experience. Jul 14, 2019 foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy. Pdf research paradigm and the philosophical foundations. Coseru on dunne, foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy hnet. Dharmakirti s tradition in india and tibet the epistemological turn in indian philosophy the place of dharmakirti in indian buddhism dharmakirti s tradition in tibet foundation of the sagya scholastic tradition a conflict of interpretations sagya commentators the rise of the geluk tradition the origin and significance of sectarian divisions. The buddhist path combines both philosophical reasoning and meditation. Pdf dharmakirti, davidson, and knowing reality researchgate. Lucid and carefully argued, dunne s work serves both as an introduction to dharmakirti for students of buddhism and a groundbreaking resource for. Dharmakirtis vadanyaya, the logic of debate peter kirby. Dharmakirtis synthesis is the apex of buddhist philosophy, at the moment when it was institutionally fading. It will also revisefor the betterthe way haikai is taught.
The philosophical works and influence of dignaga and dharmakirti. The continuing surge in work on dharmakirti represents one of the most fertile enterprises within the field of buddhist studies. Nalanda was still bustling, buoyed by cosmopolitan incursions of brahmans and lay students, but the weeds were growing around the deserted stupas not just in the south but in northern india as well. The word biofield is a term that western scientists have used to describe various aspects of energy and information fields that guide health processes. Roger jackson summarizes dharmakirtis arguments against permanent self and creator god in his article. Dharmakirti s selfengendered conversion convinced him that buddha is the ultimate source of all knowledge, leading him to try to unravel the inner logic of the teachings.
Masterfully unpacking these foundations of dharmakirtis system, john dunne presents the first major study of the most vexing issues in dharmakirtis thought within its indian philosophical context. Buddhist epistemology for buddhist thinkers philosophy should aid one in eliminating suffering and obtaining happiness. What gets called philosophy of religion in most philosophy departments and journals is really the philosophy of abrahamic religion. Dharmakirti author of philosophy of religion and advaita. Orthodox accounts continue to present knowledge as a linguistic, logical quality, expressed in statements or theories that are well justified by evidence and actually true. Dharmakirtis renowned works, written in india during the philosophically rich seventh century, argue that the true test of knowledge is its efficacy, and likewise that only the. Masterfully unpacking these foundations of dharmakirti s system, john dunne presents the first major study of the most vexing issues in dharmakirti s thought within its indian philosophical context. Dunne, 9780861711840, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
Dharmakirtis great achievement lay in showing how these could all be integrated by using the theory of knowledge as an overarching framework. Dharmakirti is the author of philosophy of religion and advaita vedanta 4. An annotated translation of the fourth chapter parathanumana, volum bilingual, 2000. Dharmakirtis philosophy and its tibetan interpreters. There are nigrahasthanas of the disputatant asadhanangavacana and of the opponent adosodbhavana. Ensures that the most recent developments in the philosophy of mind and cognitive science are brought together into a coherent, accessible whole. Giuseppe ferraro metaphyysics journal of indian philosophy 41 2. Buddhist philosophy refers to the philosophical investigations and systems of inquiry that developed among various buddhist schools in india following the parinirvana i.
Index to volume 58, philosophy east and west deepdyve. Dunne is a professor of buddhist studies at emory university in atlanta. Recognizing reality dharmakirtis philosophy and its. Shcherbatskoy wrote in buddhist logic translating dharmakirtis logic manual something like this senses can directly perceive only one moment, but there is a chain of moments that enters our consciousness, thanks to the activity of mentation which unites them in regard to that moment on the basis of sensual perception. In foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy 2004, he examines the most prominent buddhist theories of perception, language, inference and justification. His holiness the dalai lamas teaching on the 2nd chapter of dharamkirtis pramanavarttika given in riga, latvia on october 10, 2016. Localist lessons from puritan and confucian communities, russell arben fox, 1. Read unlimited books and audiobooks on the web, ipad, iphone and android. Indeed in dharmakirtis case, most of his philosophy is presented from a. The 2nd chapter of dharmakirtis the 14th dalai lama. His work has focused on the neuropsychology of alzheimers disease and other agerelated neurological disorders, memory selfmonitoring, the biological bases of emotion, and emotion response and. Dharmakirtis philosophy and its tibetan interpretations. He wanted to achieve valid knowledge through causalsequence in our experience.
Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Berkeleylos angeles, university of california press, 2003. His accomplishments rank with those of aristotle, avicenna. Introduction the pram6navdrttika hereafter pv was the most extensive and ambitious work on epistemology to be written by dharmakirti ft. Dec 16, 20 what follows is a description of dharmakirtis vadanyaya, the logic of debate. Most of the questions addressed in those discussions are simply irrelevant to most of the worlds other religious traditions. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy studies in indian and tibetan buddhism. Selected bibliography on buddhist logic and ontology. David braddonmitchell and frank jacksons popular introduction to philosophy of mind and cognition is now available in a fully revised and updated edition. Mangala chinchore, states in the introduction that roughly speaking, the present work is directed at articulating and assessing the worth of dharmakirtis theory of anumana as presented in his hetubindu, although references to his other works.
Beautiful, poignant, at times humorous, transcendent, messy, down to earth, refreshingly honestthe book explores death, and more importantly, being alive, through a rich mix of personal stories and spiritual reflections. Dunne throughout the history of buddhism, few philosophers have attained the stature of dharmakirti, the lord of reason who has influenced virtually every systematic buddhist thinker since his time. Read foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy online by. He was one of the key scholars of epistemology in buddhist philosophy, and is associated with the yogacara and sautrantika schools. In this book, rajendra prasad uses the method of contemporary logic to clarify dharmakirtis system of inference.
Dharmakirti s great achievement lay in showing how these could all be integrated by using the theory of knowledge as an overarching framework. Indeed, dharmakirtis influence effectively eclipsed dignagas, and for. Download pdf dharmakirti on the duality of the object. During the golden age of ancient indian civilization, dharmakirti articulated and defended buddhist philosophical principles. The life of dharmakirti, a profound and rigorous philosopher of indian buddhism, is a subject of hagiography with little solid data upon which we can confidently rely.
Foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy mark siderits. Dharmakirtis theory of hetucentricity of anumana by mangala r. His work focuses on various aspects of buddhist philosophy and contemplative practice. Download fulltext pdf download fulltext pdf research paradigm and the philosophical foundations of a qualitative study article pdf available january 2019 with 4,175 reads. Shcherbatskoy wrote in buddhist logic translating dharmakirti s logic manual something like this senses can directly perceive only one moment, but there is a chain of moments that enters our consciousness, thanks to the activity of mentation which unites them in regard to that moment on the basis of sensual perception. Both dharmakirti in his theory of apoha and davidson in his theory of triangulation argued that the content of words or concepts.
Intensive teachings on dharmakirti s pramanavarttika by the eminent scholar venerable geshe dorji damdul. Recognizing reality dharmakirtis philosophy and its tibetan interpretations georges b. Nov 12, 2008 index to volume 58 index to volume 58 20081112 00. Intensive teachings on dharmakirti s pramanavarttika by. Dharmakirti is one of the worlds great philosophers. Review of dunne, foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy. The compendium of the higher teaching philosophy asanga, walpola rahula, sara boinwebb there are two systems of abhidharma, according to tibetan tradition, lower and higher. By turns humorous and moving, this beautifully written memoir demystifies zen training, casting its profound insights in simple, lucid language, and takes the reader. Read foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy by john d. His current research includes an inquiry into the notion of mindfulness in both classical. Buddhist philosophy before dharmakirti and his immediate predecessor dignaga had consisted largely of discussions on a set of core topics in metaphysics. Nov 12, 2008 foundations of dharmakirtis philosophy.
Dharmakirti s renowned works, written in india during the philosophically rich seventh century, argue that the true test of knowledge is its efficacy, and likewise that only the efficacious is knowable and real. What follows is a description of dharmakirtis vadanyaya, the logic of debate. Throughout the history of buddhism, few philosophe. This book celebrates the great stripping process of aging, dying and spiritual awakening. Biofield is a term used by some scientists to describe a field of energy and information that regulates the homeodynamic function of living organisms and may play an important role in understanding basic biopsychosocial functions, especially those directing health, healing, and wellbeing see rubik et al, this issue, for a discussion on the history and current use of the term. His holiness the dalai lama s teaching on the 2nd chapter of dharamkirti s pramanavarttika given in riga, latvia on october 10, 2016. The first dharmakirti, indogaku bukkyogaku kenkyu the journal of indian.
1693 1534 900 1340 1240 327 1563 646 163 958 394 430 1347 567 115 93 209 603 1511 657 1483 538 906 1092 832 454 595 716 1613 1694 1206 30 615 245 365 1569 272 44 247 1256 509 187 683 200 201 1490 216 1016